Top 10: most-reviewed mascaras

by

When it comes to mascaras, we ladies are a wee bit fussy. But rightly so, I say. I mean, we don’t want clumpy, thin, stumpy lashes do we? Nope. We want fluttery, full, sexy eyelashes. Always. However, finding the product that gives us all those things and more is tough. Very tough.

That’s why we’ve pulled together the top 10 most-reviewed mascaras tested by our brilliant bh members. They’ve tried them – and then they’ve spilled the beans. So, read their literary works of genuis below, and we’re certain you’ll feel completely confident the next time you’re searching for a product that’s truly got the lash-enhancing goods…

TOP 10 MOST-REVIEWED MASCARAS ON BEAUTYHEAVEN

#10:Maybelline New York Full ‘n Soft Mascara

Designed to add colour and volume to the lashes while also protecting them, this make-up must-have contains vitamin E for soft, fluttery lashes 24/7.

Reviewers said…
The best mascara I’ve used! No clumpy lashes and no smudging through the day, I love it 🙂 – Janeka
It’s also great because your lashes actually do feel soft after the mascara dries, which is extremely rare – usually my lashes feel quite spiky with mascara on! – Summerstar77
Read more reviews…

#9:Rimmel London 1-2-3 Looks Mascara  
With its nifty twistable packaging, this goodie lets you customise your lashes as you see fit – just turn the dial for your desired volume.

Reviewers said…
I’ve gone through two tubes of this now since I discovered it 🙂 It’s my everyday go-to mascara. – Vkan
Best invention. Customizable levels? GENIUS! why wasn’t this thought of before? – susan8D
Read more reviews…

#8:Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Mascara
This gem stretches lashes to extreme limits while providing volume, curl, definition and shine at the same time.

Reviewers said…
Maybelline are the queens of amazing mascaras and this is another great one. – Summerstar77
It separates the lashes perfectly and gives them a natural-looking curl. It doesn’t clump (thank god!) and did I mention it’s perfect? – makeupdiva23
Read more reviews…

#7: Maybelline New York Define-A-Lash Mascara  

This flexible brush not only creates long, flawless lashes, but separates each lash from root to tip without leaving clumps, too. Win!

Reviewers said…
I don’t know what I’d do without this mascara! Even at the end of the tube I still do not experience clumpiness. – ken8989
This mascara will do what it needs to do; give you elongated, black lashes without spider leg effect, without excessive smudging, without any problems. – NellAdams
Read more reviews…

#6: COVERGIRL LashExact Mascara
This wonder has a unique brush with evenly spaced bristles to help define and lengthen lashes while keeping them clump-free at the same time.

Reviewers said…
Even though it really only separates and lengthens (no volume) it looks so pretty and simple. It also lasts all day for me. – Jillian864
This is a great product. It doesn’t smear, rub, or flake. I really liked the bristles on the brush. It separates the lashes nicely and evenly. – Amanda738
Read more reviews…

#5: Max Factor False Lash Effect Mascara  
Claiming to double your lash size with one application, this large mascara wand uses patented Liquid Lash™ technology to leave your lashes looking thicker.

Reviewers said…
I always, always come running back to this mascara. I love its large, rubber brush, which separates my lashes perfectly.  – Auralee
I LOVE this mascara. It’s buildable, so multiple coats don’t create clumps, and most importantly it doesn’t smudge! – cliches
Read more reviews…

#4: Maybelline New York Great Lash Mascara
Designed to condition as it thickens your lashes, this mascara is much-loved for being easy to remove, too.

Reviewers said…
I love the coverage it gives attention to every lash and is great for separating and getting into those small new lashes. – Booboobaby77
This does everything you want a mascara to do! It separates lashes, it’s clump-free, provides volume at the base of your lashes and even lengthens. – discomilk
Read more reviews…

#3: Maybelline New York Volum’ Express FALSIES Mascara
Featuring unique fibres that lengthen, moisturise and give volume to eyelashes, it also comes with a convex-shaped brush for the perfect product application.

Reviewers said…
When I want something a step above natural for every day I love the Falsies mascara. It doesn’t clump, never flakes or smudges and stays all day. – Popss
This is a great and affordable mascara. It adds volume to my lashes and lengthens them. – Kathryn729
Read more reviews…

#2:COVERGIRL LashBlast Volume Mascara  
The brush wand in this volume-boosting formula contains a whole heap of tiny teeth to ensure instant volume and fullness. Added bonus: it’s smudge and smear-proof, too.

Reviewers said…
I love this stuff! My holy grail mascara. It adds a lot of volume and doesn’t dry out too fast. – is2u
I just love how it doesn’t clump my lashes whatsoever and doesn’t flake or smudge. – Beautybyte
Read more reviews…

#1:Maybelline New York Colossal Volum’Express Mascara
This lash-tastic gem delivers extreme volume thanks to its collagen formula and thickening agents. Hello, fat lashes.

Reviewers said…
I love the brush and the formula of this mascara. It really extends my lashes and makes them thick and full. I have bought this over and over again. – s2pring
I have tried probably 20 different mascaras trying to find the perfect one, and this is it. No clumping, and makes my lashes look fake yet still real. – Louisebaby8
Read more reviews…

Have you tried any of these most-reviewed mascaras? Are you keen to try any now that you’ve read the stellar reviews? What’s your go-to mascara?

PS. Loved this? Check out our list of the top 10 most-reviewed shampoos and top 10 most-reviewed foundations…

Get all the latest trends, photos and news from bh: follow us on…

Share your thoughts

Comment 1

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00