How to choose the best highlighter for you

Highlighters have been under the make-up spotlight for a while now thanks to both the contouring and strobing trends. Although the name itself is pretty self-explanatory in regards to what they’re used for (highlighting points of the face), there can be a bit of confusion when it comes to which ones to use. In fact, there are many factors to consider when choosing a highlighter including your skin type, skin tone and the finish you’re trying to achieve. So we enlisted the help of professional make-up artists - Tobi Henney (female), Eloise Proust and Sheri Vegas - to give us the best advice on how to choose the right highlighter.
When to use liquid highlighter
You may presume that liquid highlighters would be better used on dry skin, but it’s more about the finish you want to achieve rather than your skin type.
“A liquid highlighter is great to create a dewy fresh look and can also be mixed into your foundation for the ultimate summer glow, perfect for a natural day look.” - Eloise.
RELATED: 3 beauty looks to absolutely nail this summer
RELATED: 21 amazing expert make-up tips
RELATED: The celebrity make-up artist who hates contouring
Sheri backs this up by saying that liquid illuminator will “give you a softer glow”. So if you’re going for a more minimal look, or even applying to bare skin, liquid highlighter is the better option.
- e.l.f. Cosmetics Essentials Shimmering Facial Whip
- NYX Cosmetics Born to Glow Liquid Illuminator
- Models Prefer Instant Glow Face and Body Highlighter
- INIKA Light Reflect Highlighting Crème
- Benefit Cosmetics Sun Beam
When to use powder highlighter
“Powder highlighters are fantastic for [night-time] events as they last all night. Tom Ford Shade & Illuminate is an absolute must-have in my make-up kit for the perfect sheer see-through glow.” - Tobi
“I’m a fan of both liquid and powder highlights, however I do prefer powder highlighter for most of my clients, as I know it will last all day and night. I would suggest powder highlighter for a long-lasting look [like] wedding day make-up.” - Eloise
- Paula's Choice Blush & Contour Palette (bh’s Sam’s current fave)
- Mary Kay Highlighting Powder
- Klara Cosmetics Contour Me Palette
- Tom Ford Shade & Illuminate ($110, davidjones.com.au)
What about combining liquid and powder highlighters?
“If you want super high shine I recommend using both. [Apply] the liquid first and then set with a highlight powder.” - Sheri
“I tend to layer my highlighters to create the perfect glow. My favourite cream highlighter is M.A.C [Cream Colour Base in] Hush and my favourite powder highlighter is Charlotte Tilbury FilmStar Bronze & Glow ($97, www.charlottetilbury.com/au).” (bh note: This was also Eloise’s favourite powder highlighter.) - Tobi
RELATED: You HAVE to see Jennifer Lawrence's fairy make-up
RELATED: Your common beauty questions, answered by experts
RELATED: What does your lip colour say about you?
Which shade of highlighter to choose
Highlighters come in a variety of shades, with most falling into a pale pink, white or bronze/gold tone. When it comes to choosing which one, Sheri says, “It all depends on where you apply it and the skin tone you have.”
Tobi agrees, saying that “Bronze and gold highlighters look fantastic on tanned, olive skin types.
“Whereas I would do a pretty soft pink highlighter for those with fairer skin.
“White highlighters can work well on shoots on fair to medium skin types to create a sheer glow to the cheekbones.”
Eloise adds, “Make sure you don’t apply a white highlighter if you are someone with a dark complexion, because this can look way too frosty and harsh on the skin.”
When to use a shimmer highlighter
“A shimmer highlight can be applied day or night. Make sure you only apply highlighters to the parts of your face you want to bring out. I suggest [the] tops of your cheekbones, inner eyelids and Cupid’s bow.” - Eloise
“[While] some people also apply highlighter to the forehead and down the nose - you have to be very careful applying it there [especially if it has a shimmer finish] as it can sometimes look oily.” - Sheri
RELATED: 11 of the best highlighting and contouring kits
RELATED: Your favourite products in pen form
RELATED: 8 ways to use your beauty blender
When to use a matte highlighter
“You can wear a matte highlighter any time and the great thing is that it suits everyone. [Use it] along [the same] key areas that you apply your shimmer highlighter, [but] you can also use a matte highlighter under the eyes and down the t-zone.” - Sheri
“Matte highlighters are great to use down the centre of the nose to create a slimmer nose shape. Remember to contour the sides of the nose to enhance the highlight.” - Tobi
While some people assume that shimmer highlighters are the way to go, Eloise explains that
“You don’t always need shimmer to highlight.
“I love liquid and powder matte highlighters. Always highlight under the eye area with a liquid matte highlighter, which will brighten your face immediately [and] give a fresh youthful look. Don’t forget to apply product around [the] inner corners of the eyes where a lot of people tend to have a dark shadow.”
Did you find these tips helpful? What type of highlighter do you like to use?
Have you tried any of the products mentioned above?
Review them now to earn points that you can swap for free beauty products in RewardsRoom.
74 Member Comments
As someone who is hopeless with make up I have improved my looks with these handy tips.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Heya, matte highlighter? How?
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I like using highlighter but I feel to shimmery during the day.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I can't live without liquid highlighter and illuminator. I love looking dewy!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I need to grab some matte highlighter.
It really lifts the face when applied correctly!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
This is a good makeup basics article, I love the idea of cream on powder highlighter. I adore highlighters.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I rarely use highlighter because the shades don't always seem to work with my pale skin.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
This is a pretty good article for a person like me who is a beginner to highlighters! Ever since Winter has started, highlighters have come in handy to make my skin look more glowy.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Highlighter wise, I have only tried Innika, but it is gorgeous
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I'm fair and I now do lots of different colours tones. Gold pink purple etc it's quite easy if you blend it.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Very informative.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
love benefits highlighter
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I have only tried the Innika but must try some others
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Some great choices
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
It has been a while since I last read this but thank you this page has some really helpful tips, I have used a powder highlighter but only sometimes since I am scared that I will look oily with a liquid one.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Just added this article to my favorite!! I layer my highlighter too!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Highlighting can be really pretty but it is a fine line to walk because if you go overboard it can look terrible, especially as you get older. Wrinkly fairies aren't cute at all!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
In general, I would agree warm skin tones do better with gold highlighters and cool skin tones with pink. However, there are some people (me included) who have warm skin tones - and look better with pink highlighters. Otherwise I look too yellow. Vs the pink, which gives me a healthy flush.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
the blam highlighters are okay for fair skin feels an last longs time
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
What about a stick/cream highlighter though? Also I have no clue how to apply liquid highlighter haha
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I might try mixing a little in to my foundation
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I have always struggled with liquid highlighters but love powder ones
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I personally love all benefit highlighters the pay off is incredible, the staff are lovely to and always ready to help out when needed 10/10 recommend
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0