6 yrs, 7 mths ago

What is your Holy Grail Mascara?

Help!!
I’m pretty sure they’re deleting my ultimate favourite mascara L’Oreal False Lash Effect Butterfly Wings and I don’t know what to do!!
I have hyped this mascara for years, nothing compares!! I’ve tried the other False Lash varieties and there is just no comparison…
L’Oreal do fantastic mascaras but I’m going to need help finding a mascara that will give me lashes so huge, so fat and long that they look fake.
Any suggestions?
What do you use?

76 comments 32 voices

Replies

  • Bronze
    6 yrs, 3 mths ago

    I would try chemist wharehouses w7 range I can never get a great mascara and I always hate how new mascara wands have too much product on them when they are new but I tried the falsie effect one in this range (w7) and I’ve never been so surprised and at $5 each you could afford to try the six different mascaras they have !! And most f the w7 range s amazing

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    I can’t really afford it but I love Georgio Armani’s Eyes to Kill mascara

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    Someone else recommended it as I haven’t tried Stilas mascara. You’re right though, everyone wants something specific. . If I had my way I’d try them all!!

    I did recently purchase L’Oreal’s Lash Paradise (along with L’Oreal Infallible Pro Glow foundation that isn’t sold here). The Lash Paradise is supposed to be a Better Than sex dupe. I’ve seen it being hyped on Insta from the US/UK so I’m excited about trying that. Downside is it could be a month until I get it as I have ordered it from Arizona.

    • 6 yrs, 3 mths ago

      I would really like to know how you go with the loreal lash paradise.
      Mascara is so hard to review

      • 6 yrs, 3 mths ago

        I got it today and applied it over my tired already made up Eyes that only have a handful of extensions left and I have to say, it looks promising!!

        I looked it up for Kendall on instagram, and it was only $22.27 on eBay which is less than L’Oreal mascaras cost here.. I just saw that you have a girlfriend in the states. Omg I would be asking for so much!! I want the glossier range!!!
        Anyway I found Lash Paradise through a seller called special spice if anyone is interested 🙂
        I’ll keep you updated x

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    It’s funny Emma ocean , I was recently trying the stila mascara you mentioned. I don’t like it. It didn’t do anything for me.
    Just shows mascara is so personal.

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    For a long time it was Too Faced’s Better Than Sex Mascara

    BUT I tried Stila’s Huge Extreme Lash yesterday (which is supposedly ‘a dupe’) and dare I say… I love it more than my long-time holy grail.

    Oh and I also love Modelco’s LASH XTEND 🙂

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    ooooh!! Mine is Covergirl Lash Blast

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    estee lauder

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    Definitely love the Benefit They’re Real. I loooooove this.

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    I really like Maybelline Hypercurl Mascara. It’s cheap and you don’t have to apply more than once for it to add volume on your eyelashes.

  • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

    I used to use high end mascaras all the time, but found that they aren’t worth it no matter how good they are. You’re supposed to throw mascara out every 3 months and I just can’t justify spending over $30 each time I need a new one. So I’ve stuck to drugstore mascaras for many years. I am very picky with mascara though. I feel like Rimmel mascaras aren’t talked about enough. I love the Extra Super Lash Mascara by Rimmel, because it gives my eyelashes so much added length! It also doesn’t clump or flake, which I appreciate in any mascara. I don’t care much for volumising mascaras, but Covergirl has some great ones if this is what you’re after. The Maybelline Great Lash and Colossal mascaras are great. The Physicians Formula Sexy Booster Va Va Voom Bolume mascara smells absolutely amazing and has the prettiest packaging!

    • 6 yrs, 4 mths ago

      Yes, I totally agree. I feel like most people ignore the expiry dates on their makeup products but I personally think that when it comes to eye products expiry dates are important! My holy grail mascara is probably Essence False Lash Mascara, it`s so cheap ($5?), lengthening and volumising. Also no smudging throughout the day even with my oily eyelids.

  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.