I just tried the BYS eyeliner pen in black and was so surprised that it is a good product since it is quite cheap. I bought it at Kmart for about $7.95. The applicator and tip make it easy to use and it dries quickly so the product doesn’t smudge.
My favourite drug store liners are Rimmel liquid eyeliner and Maybelline Master Precise Curvitude liner. Both are value for money, the Maybelline liner is more precise (as per name) especially if you’re going for cat eyes.
I have hooded eyes and have always loved Maybelline Master Precise! It is thin and easy to use allowing for such a more superior control and helps reduce mess ups! It also doesn’t smudge if you blink too suddenly too!
My holy grail liquid eyeliner is the NYX Matte Liquid Liner. It’s affordable, lasts for AGES and it’s the only one I am able to get a crisp wing with effortlessly. Try it, I have to have at least 2 backups on me at all times, I can’t live without it.
Personally I love the Maybelline Hyper Sharp & Master Precise, as well as the NYX matte liquid liner, all super affordable, and if you’re interested in trying Korean brands, I’d highly recommend Innisfree’s real lasting eyeliner, because it’s really affordable and doesn’t budge at all throughout the day, even when I have watery eyes from allergies!