makeupcatPlatinumMakeupcat
Platinum
6 yrs, 11 mths ago

Britney Spears: Fantasy vs Midnight Fantasy

I’m having such a hard time deciding between the two! They have such amazing reviews on BH – can’t believe the original has 500+ reviews. That’s insane!

Which one do you prefer and why? Yeah, I’ve never smelled them before – bit delayed here!! Both sound so delicious and the notes are right up my alley! Gotta say I hate the bottle though, I think that’s the reason why I never looked into it all these years…

Also it’s on sale at Chemist Warehouse for anyone else who is also interested 😉

30ml / $12.99
100ml / $19.99

16 comments 32 voices

Replies

  • Trudyjarrod
    Bronze
    Trudyjarrod
    6 yrs, 8 mths ago

    I love Midnight Fantasy and every time I wear it I get complimented on how nice I smell.

    Reply Report
    • makeupcatPlatinumMakeupcat
      Platinum
      6 yrs, 8 mths ago

      Yes I adore MF… so fruity and fun! Feels like a splash of fresh, sweet goodness.

      Reply Report
  • Caitlinamelia
    Bronze
    Caitlinamelia
    6 yrs, 11 mths ago

    It’s like the taco commercial! You should get both

    Reply Report
  • the_girl_who_loves_cosmeticsPlatinumThe_girl_who_loves_cosmetics
    Platinum
    6 yrs, 11 mths ago

    I am not much help with this particular question as I just love both.

    Reply Report
    • makeupcatPlatinumMakeupcat
      Platinum
      6 yrs, 11 mths ago

      I TOTALLY get you haha! I ended up buying both and I ADORE them equally – they`re both different for me. I went in thinking I`d prefer one over the other, but I now understand why people can`t decide between the two. When I`m feeling lazy/laid back I spray Fantasy, when I`m feeling energetic/excited I spray Midnight Fantasy.

      Reply Report
  • Stephanie2494PlatinumStephanie2494
    Platinum
    6 yrs, 11 mths ago

    Personally I preferred midnight fantasy. I found the original a little overpowering for me (I am not a massive fan of sweet selling scents) They both have great wear though. I would say go for both. They are both nice scents considering the price.

    Reply Report
    • Stephanie2494PlatinumStephanie2494
      Platinum
      6 yrs, 11 mths ago

      Although my favourtie scent by Britney is in control curious. I had when it was 13/14 and then I couldn`t find it for years. A few months back I saw it one them places in the middle of the shopping centers (I think they are called my beauty spot, they are associated with chemist warehouse). It is a really nice perfume (and it comes in a really nice bottle)

      Reply Report
      • makeupcatPlatinumMakeupcat
        Platinum
        6 yrs, 11 mths ago

        Thank you Stephanie! Everyone is recommending I get both so I will – as they must smell great then!

        I just searched up Control Curious. Why do all the notes in her perfume sound so amazing?! This is also right up my alley. Oh gosh, I feel like I may start collecting her scents at some point – something I thought I`d never do! Plus it`d be satisfying to have about 4-5 of them as well LOL

        Reply Report
  • Trish_DPlatinumTrish_D
    Platinum
    6 yrs, 11 mths ago

    Makeupcatxo, I’m totally off topic but know you’ll see this because it’s your thread. I couldn’t reply to you via the Home Page blog because the function wasn’t working, now I’ve “lost” it!!!

    The half price Beautorium I mentioned and you’d not heard of was a few Beautoriums ago and EVERY item was available for only half the points – it was brilliant as you can imagine and I splurged!!! So much so that I’m still behind in my points balance! Unfortunately half price isn’t going to happen often, if ever!

    Reply Report
    • makeupcatPlatinumMakeupcat
      Platinum
      6 yrs, 11 mths ago

      Oh my goodness thank you SO much Trish for the reply! You`re too wonderful!! 🙂

      I can`t believe that actually happened. EVERY item. WOW!! I probably wasn`t active on the site at the time and that`s why I`d never even heard of it until now. Darn it!! HAHA everyone would have had such a blast swapping points!

      Well I plan to be a very loyal BH member now so hopefully a miracle happens and it occurs again 😉

      Thank you again Trish ❤❤❤

      Reply Report
      • Trish_DPlatinumTrish_D
        Platinum
        6 yrs, 11 mths ago

        My pleasure, makeupcatxo. Lovely to have you being active now. It most definitely was super wonderful and I was so lucky because I had a decent points balance! Not any longer!

        Reply Report
  • ThisIsMePlatinumThisIsMe
    Platinum
    6 yrs, 11 mths ago

    I prefer fantasy as it is slightly lighter & more “fresh” but as duality mentioned buy both in the smaller size as they are so cheap 🙂

    Reply Report
    • makeupcatPlatinumMakeupcat
      Platinum
      6 yrs, 11 mths ago

      You guys have convinced me! It`d be so cute having the two bottles together too. Thank you! I`ll save Midnight Fantasy for occasional night time wear 🙂

      Reply Report
  • dualityPlatinumDuality
    Platinum
    6 yrs, 11 mths ago

    I have both and the midnight one is much heavier – really sweet and heavy (fruity vanilla) and to be honest it can be overpowering if you spray too much and it can give me a headache if I am a little stressed (prone to migraines). It lasts forever on the skin great for night time.

    The original pink one is lovely, lighter and more sweet, sugary, candy in scent. I prefer this one over the midnight because it wears well but isn’t so overpowering.

    They are super cheap now in Chemists Warehouse – get the little bottles (forgot the mls) because you can have both!

    Reply Report
    • makeupcatPlatinumMakeupcat
      Platinum
      6 yrs, 11 mths ago

      Thank you duality your comments always help me so much 🙂

      I think I remember scrolling through the reviews and seeing yours too!

      Reply Report
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.