Maybelline New York - Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil

Rating: Feb 11, 2013 10:16pm

would never buy anything else

this is a great eyeliner, the best i have ever tried. and for the price it is the best value for money!

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Maogirl.

Rating: Dec 23, 2012 7:42pm

Not a great product

At first I semi enjoyed this product. It was not super pigmented but you could still work with it, it had a fairly small tip (however couldn't be sharpened) so it was good for drawing liner on my upper lashline, however it did drag a bit..

Then I tried to use it on my waterline... not a good result.
I even cleaned my waterline with a cotton bud beforehand so there was no oil or anything to prevent the liner not applying but no luck. This was terrible! It dragged so much that it actually hurt. The only hint that I had tried to apply it was the faint grey line i managed to get out of it, and the redness from where it had pulled.

I also found the product dried out very quickly, I never stored it without the cap or in unusual heat or cold yet in a few weeks it had dried hard and brittle.

Would not recommend if you want to use it on your waterline. Okay for top lashline. Nothing special. Can get much better for the price

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Amber382.

Rating: Oct 31, 2012 10:50pm

No way near as good as maybellines unstoppable eyeliner

I've been using maybelline unstoppable eyeliner for years, so when eye studio master eyeliner came out I couldn't wait to try it. I was very disappointed. I bought it in black and it's very light in colour. It has great staying power but doesn't go on easily and it's no good for the waterline.

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Julie130.

Rating: Sep 30, 2012 1:44am

Not so black

I expected the pencil to be creamy and soft but when it came to applying - it was like a normal crayon and sometimes drag on the skin.
Colour was the most disappointing. It was not a deep solid black as I hoped.

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Magztaa.

Rating: Sep 16, 2012 8:20pm

Great durability

There are a few things I don't like about this eyeliner. For starters, I purchased it in brown, and was instantly disappointed to find that it's really just a dull grey/black. It's also not very creamy.. just an ordinary smooth eye pencil.Also isn't fantastic on the water line.

It does have its merits however, it is very pigmented and doesn't smudge even when swimming. So, pretty good, but nothing all that special.

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Inga409.

Rating: Jul 31, 2012 7:04pm

creamy texture

While this is a perfectly good liner I prefer the master precision liner by maybelline instead.
This gives a heavier line.
The application is pretty simple and I like that you dont need any sharpeners. But I prefer a clean line look for everyday wear.
This is good for a smoky eye.

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Fashionista8P.

Rating: Jul 10, 2012 3:31pm

A great liner!

I've been wearing eyeliner for as long as I can remember eating solids! I started with the kohl liners that I had to sharpen and now use the precision liners that twist up. This liner was nice to use and stays on all day. It wasn't as easy to apply as my usual liner and by this I mean that the colour didn't go on as easily as usual; I had to repeat the lining a few times before I got a true colour. I would also prefer a 'smudger' on the end but aside from these small gripes, it's a great liner and I would recommend.

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Nic990.

Rating: May 21, 2012 11:46am

A bit disappointed but not too bad.

I agree with the reviewer above who said it does not apply well to the waterline! I would not recommend purchasing if this is why you want it.

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by Style by Kirsten.

Rating: Apr 21, 2012 9:25pm

Long lasting and affordable

I've been wanting to try this for quite some time now, and after seeing it on sale for $9 at Priceline, I just had to get it.

I usually have problems with my eyeliner lasting all day as I tend to get oily eyelids, but this eyeliner didn't budge. In fact I could only properly remove it with make-up remover.

I found it quite easy to apply, especially on the top lids. I would definitely recommend this an affordable must have eyeliner!

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by chntlove.

Rating: Apr 20, 2012 1:36pm

Does not go on the waterline.

I bought this eyeliner in black to use on my waterline. It just does go on at all.

On the top eyelid it is an okay eyeliner, but overall, as I wanted to use this on my waterline, I was very disappointed. Especially because on the packet it said 'for a dramatic effect apply to the waterline'.

Read the full review of Eye Studio Master Liner Cream Pencil by honey_bee.