Best Eye Pencil Ever!

I use Shavata’s Double-Ended Pencil. It has two different shades good for staying away from big square block brows.

For me, my best eye pencils are anything Estee Lauder. They glide on so easily and smoothly, stay all day and smell amazing. They are pricey though, so in the meantime I’ll use Revlon. 🙂

Might be a bit too late but I thought if chime in anyway. My absolute favourite black eye pencil from Prestige cosmetics called the Total Intensity eyeliner. They come in a few different shades and I’ve got 5 of them I believe. They’re very comparable to Urban Decay Perversion but a bit cheaper. Unfortunately, the brand isn’t stocked at all Priceline stores but if you don’t mind making a trip to the city (where I always get mine) or ordering online, it’s worth a shot. I have tried quite a few different brands and this is the best one that I’ve found especially if you wear shimmery or even glittery eyeshadows. They glide over everything and are very opaque.

I love NP Set pencil eyeliner. Easy to apply, glides on smoothly, quite pigmented, and almost fool proof for a beginner like me, haha. The only con is that it smudged easily.

Wow! Some fantasticly experienced and interesting recommendations – thankyou – I’m loving hearing about your fave eye liners! Such an important part of every girls make-up bag. : )

For a day time look I love Clinique’s Cream Shaper For Eyes in “Egyptian” – it’s less harsh than black and stays put!. Also a fan of Stila Smudge sticks – particularly “Lionfish” for day time. I also love Urban Decay’s All Nighter Eyeliner (shade is Perversion) for when I want more impact and wow it is AMAZING – I like it because unlike the 24/7 Glide on pencils it’s retractable so doesn’t require sharpening and has fantastic staying power.

I should add – these are all eyeliners that do not make my eyes water – for some reason some eyeliners just make my eyes water and end up a mess!

Maybelline Masterliner. It’s a drugstore eye pencil but I haven’t found anything more effective!

Makeup forever aqua eyes. The only pencil that is close in pigment in staying power to gel/liquid that I have tried.

I’ve been loving Stila Smudge Sticks lately – they are really soft and very pigmented. Just a pleasure to work with, unfortunately not the cheapest…

I actually picked up the Avon Ultra Luxury Eyeliner a while back for about $4.50. I had low expectations as it was quite cheap but it’s actually quite good.