Gel Liners: Mac, Bobbi Brown or Nars?

I’ve tried the MAC but I actually loved the Napoleon gel eyeliner, really easy to apply and great staying power 🙂

I have only tried the Bobbi Brown one and I loved it! It went on great and it stayed on all day 🙂

I love gel liners… great choice!

I can’t comment on the Nars but I’ve used the MAC and the Bobbi Brown a lot. Especially for a beginner I would definitely recommend Bobbi Brown. It’s more of a creamy consistency so it doesn’t go anywhere you don’t want it. They also don’t dry out very quickly. I had one that I accidentally didn’t do the lid up very tightly on and left it a few weeks, that one dried out a bit but I used a makeup pad to wipe off the dried out layer and the rest was great. I also find the colour range gorgeous, so many subtleties of black, grey and brown.

The MAC fluid line is more liquid-y to apply, dries out quicker and I don’t buy it anymore unless I’m looking for a bright colour that doesn’t exist in the Bobbi Brown range.

I would say they equally wear well and no need to prime with either.

Just in case they recommend it at Mecca – the Stila smudge pots are super beautiful but they dry out unbelievably quickly. Definitely do not recommend!