We’re never more excited than when a celebrity pulls out a brand new hair ‘do for us to drool over. You know, a new hairstyle that really gets the creative juices flowing and reminds that it’s okay to jump out of your comfort zone and try something different.

Unfortunately, sometimes even the most well-known and well-connected celebrities get it terribly wrong. So go on, secure your judge’s hats and decide which of these celebrity hair looks need to stay, and which definitely need to go (far, far away.)

Which celebrity do you think pulls off both styles best?